Amid a churning AI market and Playboy: Wet & Wild 1 (1989)increasing anxiety about the role of AI in the creation of works of art, the U.S. government has set a strong benchmark: If a human isn't involved, it's not worth legal protections.
Part of a far-reaching report on AI and copyright, the U.S. Copyright Office has interpreted that unedited outputs of generative AI tools don't qualify for federal copyright shelter. The decision comes as part of a years-long AI initiative that set out to answer several outstanding legal questions as the AI boom ramped up, including if the U.S. Constitution's Copyright Clause permits protection for AI-generated material.
"The outputs of generative AI can be protected by copyright only where a human author has determined sufficient expressive elements," writes the office in the report's second installment, issued Jan. 29. "This can include situations where a human-authored work is perceptible in an AI output, or a human makes creative arrangements or modifications of the output, but not the mere provision of prompts."
Works that use generative AI in their creative process or that include AI-generated material areeligible, as they still retain "the centrality of humancreativity" rather than having AI stand-in for human creators, Shira Perlmutter, register of copyrights and director of the U.S. Copyright Office, explained. "Extending protection to material whose expressive elements are determined by a machine, however, would undermine rather than further the constitutional goals of copyright."
That means that images or videos created by tools like Midjourney or OpenAI's DALL-E 3 can't be copyrighted by their individual generators, even if said person wrote a complex, entirely original prompt to generate the content. Prompts alone aren't up for copyright either, and neither are successive iterations on such content.
SEE ALSO: Yes, Popeye can eat spinach: Everything you need to know about Public Domain Day 2025The office's report lays out further guidelines for the "level" of human involvement in creating AI art using assistive technologies, including the use of computer generated images in the filmmaking process. A key factor in the office's decision was the unpredictability of a generative AI output, which can produce different results with the same, or similar prompts.
"Although entering prompts into a generative AI system can be seen as similar to providing instructions to an artist commissioned to create a work, there are key differences. In a human-to-human collaboration, the hiring party is able to oversee, direct, and understand the contributions of a commissioned human artist," the report explains. "The gaps between prompts and resulting outputs demonstrate that the user lacks control over the conversion of their ideas into fixed expression."
A third part of the report, set to release later this year, will elucidate on the role of copyright in training AI models and generative AI tools on original, protected materials.
Topics Artificial Intelligence
The British media just roasted Donald Trump, and he hated itBlind man makes selfMuslim group subtly trolls Trump with 'Making America Great' billboardsApple finally streamed its big event on YouTube. Here's how many people watched.Last minute iPhone rumor: No reverse wireless chargingHalf of Americans think their cybersecurity is worse than 5 years agoThe chaotic evil 'Don't have a bookmark?' meme is out of controlCabin's 'moving hotel' bus returns with more spacious sleeping spaceIs the gig economy bill a disaster or triumph for rideApple unveils iPhone 11 Pro and iPhone 11 Pro Max with triple camerasWatch Tesla's Model S set a record lap at Laguna SecaWhat one 'Supergirl' story arc taught me about coming outEd Sheeran's tweet about his new GQ cover is classic Ed SheeranApple Watch Series 5 will come with 'always on' Retina displayApple's iPhone event: Everything that's been revealedAll the trailers from Disney+Apple unveils iPhone 11 Pro and iPhone 11 Pro Max with triple camerasThis is why the iPhone 11 doesn't have 5GApple Watch Series 5 will come with 'always on' Retina displayFather teaches his son the ABCs with a little help from trap music Amazon Spring Sale 2025: Best cinch Amazon Big Spring Sale: My favorite power bank is 50% off U.S. security officials' passwords found online, including people in Signal chat Amazon Spring Sale 2025: Save 44% on Soundcore Space A40 earbuds Amazon Big Spring Sale 2025: Best iPad deals Amazon Spring Sale 2025: Best Anker portable power station deal Over 25 beauty deals under $25 to shop during Amazon's Big Spring Sale Best robot vacuum deal from the Amazon Big Spring Sale Nintendo Direct March 27 livestream: How to watch live today OpenAI's Studio Ghibli Target Circle Week 2025: Shop deals on Peacock, Beats, Lego, and more Big Spring Sale Audible deal: 3 months for $0.99/month Nintendo confirms live NYT Connections Sports Edition hints and answers for March 28: Tips to solve Connections #186 Amazon Big Spring Sale 2025: All the best Roomba deals Amazon Spring Sale 2025: Best Jackery portable power station deal Amazon Big Spring Sale: Coleman tent for under $75 Auburn vs. Michigan 2025 livestream: How to watch March Madness for free Amazon Big Spring Sale 2025: Save $300 on Google Pixel 9 Pro Big Spring Sale deal: Buy 2, get 1 free on movies, music, and books at Amazon
1.4972s , 8222.8828125 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Playboy: Wet & Wild 1 (1989)】,Pursuit Information Network